Reform Changes Lead Employers to Rethink Retiree Prescription Benefits
As the nation's health care system begins to understand and address the impact of the recently enacted health care reform legislation, employers must assess their current and future retiree prescription benefit options, according to executives from Medco Health Solutions Inc. As the nation's health care system begins to understand and address the impact of the recently enacted health care reform legislation, employers must assess their current and future retiree prescription benefit options, according to executives from Medco Health Solutions Inc. (NYSE:MHS) speaking to more than 700 clients at Medco's annual Drug Trend Symposium.
The elimination of the tax advantage related to the Retiree Drug Subsidy (RDS) beginning in 2013 and the gradual closure of the Medicare Part D Coverage Gap by 2020 are two critical components of the health care reform legislation that may influence a plan sponsor's approach to providing retiree coverage.
As a result of the landmark health care legislation, signed into law on March 23, accounting rules caused employers who receive an RDS subsidy to record an accounting charge in their first quarter 2010 financial results to reflect the impact of the change in RDS tax status. These charges are estimated to be more than $14 billion nationally.
This change in law has caused some plan sponsors to make re-evaluating benefit decisions a top priority.
Currently, RDS remains the preferred approach for many taxable entities because of its tax advantages. While the RDS subsidy—28 percent of an organization's eligible retiree prescription costs--itself remains intact, the tax-free status of that subsidy will be eliminated by 2013. Medco estimates the incremental tax liability for an average taxable RDS plan sponsor to be in the range of $14 to $21 per member per month (assuming a 35 percent tax rate). A typical plan translates from millions to tens of millions of dollars of lost value annually.
"Many of the employers I have spoken to aren't looking to make an immediate change," said Mary Daschner, group president of Retiree Solutions for Medco. "They're assessing the new retiree prescription benefit landscape and weighing their options, both short and long term. Many employers feel an obligation to provide prescription benefits to their retirees. For others, collective bargaining agreements or other contractual obligations require them to provide retiree prescription benefits. Whatever the circumstances, plan sponsors are looking to optimize their approach in the post-reform environment, and to balance financial savings, legal commitments and administrative burdens."
The change in RDS tax status will spur more employers to consider other Medicare Part D solutions, such as the employer group waiver plan (also known as an EGWP or "egg whip"). An employer using an EGWP contracts with a Medicare-contracted prescription drug plan (PDP) to provide group benefits under Medicare Part D.
The EGWP product has garnered substantial interest in recent months because it can facilitate customized benefit designs, help an employer retain sponsorship of their retiree benefit plan at a lower cost - in addition to limited member disruption - and provide employers with options for member cost sharing and premium contributions. The government subsidy available under an EGWP is expected to increase over time--eventually outpacing the RDS subsidy--due to the gradual elimination of the coverage gap under Medicare Part D.
This increased government subsidy, coupled with the elimination of the tax advantage related to the RDS, has made the EGWP product a worthwhile solution for employers to consider as they evaluate the future of their employer-based retiree benefits.
Depending on an employer's ability and willingness to modify benefits, they can save up to 50 percent or more of their current retiree prescription drug costs by moving into an EGWP solution, while still offering a richer level of benefits than those available to retirees on the open market. This savings also assists employers in reducing their other post-employment benefit obligations (OPEB) over time, which is of significant interest for both tax-paying and non-tax paying plan sponsors.
By moving to an EGWP, one Medco client, the Kentucky Teachers' Retirement System, realized significant savings.
"The reason that KTRS opted to move to an EGWP plan off calendar year was due to the fact that we can collect deeper federal subsidies than Medicare Part D RDS, primarily via lower insured premiums," said Jane Gilbert, director of benefits at KTRS. "In addition, we realize a reduction in risk and quantify liability by locking into a set premium. We will also experience a reduction in OPEB liability of almost $1 billion."
According to Daschner, EGWP gives employers the ability to customize a benefit design and retain sponsorship or the retiree benefit at a lower cost and with limited member disruption.
"Our internal research shows that retirees are overwhelmed by the choice in the individual market, with nine of 10 retirees appreciating endorsement of a plan or guidance from their employer, Daschner said. “The EGWP can provide flexibility in plan design and premium contribution levels, which can generate savings equal to or better than RDS once the tax exemption is eliminated in 2013, while also providing peace of mind for the retiree. Employer plan sponsors should be working with a partner that can run financial models and discuss the administrative and operational aspects of various retiree prescription benefit options to determine the strategy that is right for them."
"It is likely that many employer plan sponsors will either remain with the RDS or choose an EGWP, with a high percentage of them wanting to stay with a group sponsored benefit," Daschner said. "For employers where funding the benefit is no longer viable, for whatever the reason, there are always other options available, including commercial benefits that wrap around a Part D plan and 'coordinator' models that help make the transition into the open market easier for the retiree."
2008 CDHC Superstar Awards: Pioneers in CDHC We've awarded top innovators in health care these coveted honors for excellence and innovation in the rapidly changing world of CDHC. Read about these outstanding companies and the people at their helm as they lead the way with innovative plan design, implementation, and leadership. Inside are the profiles of the winners and finalists in each of the 8 categories.
Counteract Rising Health Care Costs With Active Health Plan ManagementCan you Increase Employee Satisfaction While Holding Costs in Check? Yes!
New Solutions In SightBank of America Benefit Solutions enables a consistent approach to administering consumer-directed health care products.
Directed Health Care In 2007: Creating Transparency In An Opaque MarketThe Case For Credit In Consumer-Directed Health PlansWith the introduction of consumer-directed health care (CDHC), patients are faced with greater financial responsibility for services rendered. Without cash to pay for health services, patients may skip needed care.
The Aetna WayYears ago, Aetna CEO Ronald Williams went on a listening tour to learn what employers need most from their health insurance companies. He soon emerged as a visionary pioneer of the consumer-directed health care movement. Today, consumerism shapes every aspect of the company.
A Supplemental Employee Benefit Whose Time Has ComeLet’s look at the numbers. A man who reaches age 65 has a 4 in 10 chance of needing long-term care at some point in his lifetime. For women, that chance is 7 in 10. And the need is not restricted to seniors.
Let’s Be Clear: Transparency is Key to Drug CostsWhat administrators want—besides lower costs—is transparency. But what they are finding in today’s market is that transparency may be in the eyes of the beholder.
The Carrot vs. Stick Approach to Redesigning Health PlansIf employers truly want to encourage people to do the right thing, preventive health care should be covered 100 percent by health plans, and not subject to co-pays or deductibles.
Public Policy Finally May Be Catching Up: Disease Prevention, Management and TreatmentProviders often wrestle with the distinction between treatment and prevention, that can be largely dependent on individual medical histories and a wide range of additional health and lifestyle factors.
Helping Individuals Navigate CDHCIf CDHC is to succeed as a viable plan design option, consumers must have access to appropriate information to steer them through the plan selection decision process.
Keeping an Eye on HealthNational eye care benefits provider VSP Vision Care reports that nearly 75 percent of all vision benefit plans offered nationally have a voluntary element, requiring employees to contribute to the premium cost.
Sponsors of Health Savings Account Plans and High-Deductible Health Plans Need to Know:2008 Minimums and Maximums
Wellness Incentives Offer Flexible Options to Support CDHC GoalsFrom basic wellness rewards to integrated solutions, employers can tailor programs to meet every need.
Fending Off Weight Gain While Quitting TobaccoAccording to a recent study by the University of California, Berkeley and the University of Michigan, smokers gain an average of 20 pounds when quitting tobacco.
How To Insure the Success of Your Consumer-Directed Health Care ProgramSince more than half of all consumer health transactions involve pharmacy, the success or failure of consumer-directed health plans rides on the information and support available to members. Here are five fundamentals of a successful consumer-directed pharmacy plan that employers of any size can use to increase consumer-directed health plan success and adoption rates.
Integrating the Mess: Achieving True Consumer OwnershipDisease management and wellness programs give individuals the chance to improve their health, but do not have the personalized information to determine when and what programs are most appropriate.
Ease Administration with Technology BPOsSome entities offering health savings accounts (HSAs), health reimbursement arrangements and flexible spending accounts underestimate the management complexity involved.
Know Your Disability CoverageNothing is worse than finding out you've purchased a disability policy that fails to pay benefits on claims you believed would be covered.
Become a Catalyst for a High-Performance Health SystemAs the largest collective purchasers of health insurance, employers can and should drive the fundamental health system reform our country needs, and that Americans want.
Have Portal, Need Traffic!Where do consumers go for health care information and advice?
Pharmacist Coaches Reduce Chronic Disease CostFewer than 50 percent of people with chronic health conditions receive care according to evidenced-based guidelines, yet these conditions account for 75 percent of the country's medical care costs.
Value-Based Insurance DesignIt is no wonder that CDHP enrollment continues to grow among all sizes of employers. Yet CDHPs are not without critics.
Ease Administration With Technology BPOsHealth care payers, including benefits plan sponsors, self-insured companies and third-party administrators (TPAs), need to implement connectivity and automated health benefits solutions in order to expand health plan flexibility.
Become a Catalyst for a High-Performance Health SystemWe need a blueprint that will ensure that the United States has a plan for a health system that performs well across all dimensions of care.
Consumerism and the Promise of a Healthier, Wealthier AmericaThe quality of care delivered in the United States remains seriously substandard when compared to the level of excellence we demand from other industries.
Cost Containment by Working with Your BankWorking with your bank to reduce costs: can it be done?
NewsShort description
Infrastructure & ComponentsWith SITEFORUM you base your Online Business and Web Presence on a stable foundation. Because the SITEFORUM infrastructure consists of proven and stable components, these components are delivering critical business functions today. They are based on open, Internet standards delivering the benefits of security, customization, integration, scalability and investment protection.
Tools & AdministrationSITEFORUM includes a variety of useful, integrated tools that allows you to administer portals fast and easy. Powerful design manager easily adopts complex corporate designs to your portal. Easy to set up and use e-mail manager. File manager enables the uploading of hundreds of files at once to the server, as well as supporting data exchange with import & export filters.
All these tools make SITEFORUM easy-to-use and easy-to-manage anywhere, using only a Web browser.
Sales & SupportSITEFORUM has what you need to sell products and services via Web, to organize provide secure and rapid payment; to provide outstanding support in public or private forums and conferences; and to professionally deal with inquiries and complaints.